The new Prime Video series “A League of Their Own” has accomplished a feat as rare as a perfect game: a critical success that also dominates the charts. And do it with a kind of reset, where you step into the tricky waters that people might have high hopes for?
Released on Friday (August 12), the new “League of Their Own” (will open in a new tab) the series ranked #1 on FlixPatrol’s list of the most watched Prime Video series. (will open in a new tab) – Removing the military drama by Chris Pratt “Terminal List”.
The Terminal List (which itself supplanted The Boys, one of the best shows on Prime Video) was Amazon’s most watched show for 42 days. A League of Their Own has held that number one spot since Saturday (August 13), the day after it was released.
But popularity itself is far from a complete indicator for measuring a television series or show. This is where the critics come in, as the cast and crew who brought Rockford Peaches to life (and their friends and associates) are now showered with accolades. Their own league currently holds a 95% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. (will open in a new tab)up from 94% over the weekend.
All of the above are good indicators you should look into if you haven’t already, but let’s break it all down to see if A League of Their Own is the show for your own lineup.
What is A League of Their Own (2022) about?
Prime Video’s A League of Their Own adapts Penny Marshall’s 1992 film of the same name, but retains only some of the original elements. These Rockford Peaches appear during World War II as the need for men in the army pulls the guys out of MLB games, the Peaches manager is still a rough former ballplayer and they are still funded by a confectionery mogul.
However, once you get to the lineup, you will see how different things are. Carson Shaw (Abbi Jacobson) is the star of the show and he looks like a peach catcher. She is joined on the field by pitcher Lupe Garcia (Roberta Colindres), who has a hell of a hand, and two women Carson meets on the way to tryouts: slugger Joe DeLuca (Melanie Field) and charming Greta Gill (D’Arcy Carden). Oh, and their coach is Casey “Dove” Porter (Nick Offerman), a former baseball player.
But this is not the only story of the series. Unlike the movie, Prime Video’s A League of Their Own also focuses on the struggles women of color face as they try to overcome segregation in baseball. This plight is seen through Maxine “Max” Chapman, who faces difficulties everywhere.
However, throughout the series, we learn that the Peaches’ struggle to win isn’t their only difficulty. A League of Their Own is also about being gay in the 1940s. Several of the series’ characters struggle with life in the closet and fear being rejected by their families and society.
Reviews of Their Own League (2022): What the Critics Think
As noted above, the consensus for A League of Their Own is phenomenally positive, with a strong 95% on Rotten Tomatoes. Kristen Baldwin at Entertainment Weekly (will open in a new tab) praises the series for creating a “diverse and three-dimensional world that tells the story of the All-American Women’s Professional Baseball League, whereas the film, as wonderful as it was, could only show us a Hollywood glossy surface.”
Rebecca Nicholson at The Guardian (will open in a new tab) states that despite writing “like a fan of the movie,” the series “feels like a more complete version of the story. after all.”
(Image credit: Nicola Goode/Prime Video)
Daniel D’Addario at Variety (will open in a new tab) complements the series by offering “strong deep ensemble acting and a captivating drive to be open, genuinely emotional—the show is imbued with the unironic soft-heartedness that distinguished Jacobson from her Broad City comedy co-star Ilana Glaser.” He also notes that the dialogue can sometimes seem too modern, which makes “the characters so ahead of their time that it sometimes feels like they’ve come out of nowhere.”
At IndieWire (will open in a new tab)Ben Travers is less effusive, noting that “Their own league is burdened with exorbitant expectations and that can exacerbate every bump in the road. the original is smoothed out with every episode.”
Should You Watch A League Of Their Own (2022) Today?
(Image credit: Prime Video)
I’ll explain more about why I love this “League of Their Own” in a later installment, but I’ve been in awe of this show for anyone who can stand my presence since I watched it last weekend.
If you want an ensemble comedy/drama that has a bit of sport in it – it’s more of a plot twist than the soul of the show – like Ted Lasso’s, then Prime Video’s A League of Their Own is right for you. This series will especially appeal to anyone who has been waiting for something to fill the GLOW space on television since its abrupt cancellation at the end of 2020.
Today’s Best Streaming Box Deals